Returns, Refunds, Credit, Store Credit
My Cart


We strive to make your buying experience a happy one!
However, we are aware that you may not be always satisfied with a purchase. Below are the policies regarding returns and exchanges with Federalist Pens and Paper:

New Items: 30-Day returns accepted on all new pen purchases regarding our authorized brands. You can return the item within the time frame for a full refund, exchange if available, or store credit!

Used/Vintage Items: Unless noted otherwise, 30-Day returns with most vintage/used items*. You can return the item within the time frame for a full refund!

*-Regarding NOS Pens/Pencils- Pens that are New Old Stock (NOS) are items that have never been inked/tested/used. These items are NOT returnable due to their unique "as new" condition. These items are not replaceable, and cannot be resold as NOS once they have been sold. Therefore, please choose carefully when buying these items!

Please contact us at regarding returns and exchanges. Thank you for your business!
Earn Rewards!